10 Best Gutter Guards Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023

If you are searching for the best gutter guards according to consumer ratings and reports in 2023 then this post is for you.

Rain is fun, and we all are aware of the after-effects, all the dirt, leaves, and muck bring to our sewerage are not that cool.

The blocked gutters can be annoying, especially in the rainy season, when we have water everywhere around.

The easiest and quickest way to get rid of this problem is by getting the best gutter guard.

There are plenty of options available in the market but which one to choose.

In this post, I am going to review the best gutter guards as per consumer ratings and reports. So without further ado, let’s get started.

Best Gutter Guards Consumer Ratings & Reports

I have compiled a list of the 10 best gutter guards based on consumer ratings and reports 2023.

1. FlexxPoint 30-Year Gutter Cover System | US Made Gutter Guards

Check Latest Price

Features at a glance
  • Available in various color options. Efficiently prevents all types of fragments.
  • The installation is simple due to the included stainless steel fasteners.
  • It features Premium Domestic Aluminum construction. The uniquely designed product will be hidden if installed correctly.
  • Easy to handle 4-foot sections.
  • Proudly made in the USA.

Our next pick, the FlexxPoint gutter cover system, comes from a well-known and family-owned business.

Every product, including this guard system from the M.s FlexxPoint, is of premium quality.

The prominent feature of this product, as per our experts, is the fine mesh. The mesh prevents all the debris from entering the gutter.

This gutter cover system comes with stainless steel fastener. This inclusion of the fasteners makes the setup a breeze, and you can perform it by yourself.

To accommodate different types and sizes, it is available in eight different hence don’t worry about the compatibility issues; you are covered.

It is available in various sizes and multiple colors, such as black, white, and matte aluminum. So you can get the perfect match for the color of your roof.

According to consumer ratings & reports, this is the best gutter guard system that is reliable and affordable.

What We Like!
  • The installation of this gutter guard is straightforward, and you can do it by yourself.
  • It comes with an economical price tag.
  • The guard is available in different colors and a variety of sizes.
Things to Consider!
  • During our testing, we find out that the guard is not suitable in snowy conditions.

2. Raptor Gutter Guards for Leaves | Easiest Installation

Check Latest Price

Features at a glance
  • This micro-mesh gutter guard can block anything such as roof grit, pine needles, and pests. No more chokes!
  • This stainless steel guard can survive all the weather elements and will not rust.
  • Compatible with standard, 5″ wide gutter.
  • It will not void your roof warranty.
  • 25-Year Warranty.
  • It comes with rust-resistant screws and a magnetic hex head driver.

For reliable protection of your home gutter, the Raptor Stainless Steel Micro-Mesh Gutter Guard features small holes that effectively keep the tiniest debris out of your home gutters.

Made from stainless steel, this Raptor Gutter guard is corrosion-resistant and compatible with five-inch gutters.

The Raptor Gutter Guard is available in simple four-foot strips. The gutter guard slips under the silts, and the outer part of this guard is attached with screws for additional security.

The screws and all the other hardware you will require for the simple installation come with the pack. So, in this way, it saves you some bucks.

According to the gutter guard consumer ratings & reports, many users have stated this Raptor gutter guard as the most rugged gutter guard in the market.

The guard’s width is sufficient for seven-inch gutters, and the makers back their product with a generous warranty of 25-years.

What We Like!
  • The warranty period is 25-years.
  • The Raptor guard is made up of stainless steel and is corrosion-resistant.
  • It can block the finest of dirt particles.
  • It comes with all the hardware required for the installation.
Things to Consider!
  • A little bit expensive than the other gutter guards in the market.

3. Amerimax Gutter Guard | Best Gutter Guards on the Market

Check Latest Price

Features at a glance
  • The guard in Compatible with 4″, 5″, and 6″ K-style gutters.
  • The metal mesh design blocks debris and offers a smooth flow of rainwater.
  • Made from powder-coated steel for optimum protection from natural elements.
  • Easy “lock-in” installation
  • It has a 10-year limited warranty.
  • Made in the USA
For those folks who want excellent protection of their gutter and care for the appeal and looks of the property, you should try out this Amerimax gutter guard.

The Amerimax gutter guards offer the best protection for your gutter against clogging.

The Amerimax gutter guards can block all types of debris. They are effective against the smaller debris as well and will keep your gutter clean.

The protection is excellent, as is the flow of water. It keeps the debris out of the gutter but allows water to pass on freely.

The Amerimax guard is crafted from high-quality plastic materials that are reliable as well as highly durable. The mesh is sturdy enough and can survive the weight of large debris and rainwater.

These guards will fit K-style gutters irrespective of the gutter material. You can also use them with gutters made of steel and vinyl.

The installation is simple, and you will not need any special tools to install this Amerimax gutter guard.

What We Like!
  • Robust enough to survive high water pressure and all types of debris.
  • It will not lose its original shape.
  • It allows for a free and consistent flow of water in the gutter.
  • It is simple to fit the guards.
  • The guard is suitable to use with several types of gutters.
  • Weather and rust-resistant.
Things to Consider!
  • These are only available in a standard size.

4. GUTTERSTUFF EZ Gutter Guard | Easy to Instsall

Features at a glance
  • GutterStuff EZ gutter guard blocks all debris, whereas it allows water to flow through smoothly and quickly.
  • The installation of this GutterStuff Gutter Guard is simple, and it is an ideal gutter guard system for those who want cost-effective and reliable gutter protection.
  • The foam insert fits tightly in the gutter system, providing adequate coverage and protection without compromising aesthetics.
  • Not only it provides protection, but it also eliminates risks associated with gutter cleaning.
  • You can buy a product with confidence, the GutterStuff EZ guard, backed by a three-year warranty.
Our next pick, the GUTTERSTUFF EZ guard system, is ideal for those who want a perfect gutter guard that is easy to install and comes with an affordable price tag.

This product features a gutter filter insert. So you will not find any screen or mesh surface in this gutter guard system.

Instead, it features flat bottom foam to absorb the water and allows it to pass through the gutters; conversely, the upper part of the surface filters and block all the debris.

According to the makers, it will also prevent standing water in the gutter. This also means that you will not find any bugs in the water.

The other that caught our attention was its no-show protection. If installed correctly, the foam will remain hidden from your sight, which results in maintaining the look of your roof.

As it is a foam, you might be doubting its effectiveness and durability. But during our testing, we didn’t find any issues, but it also depends on how you use the guard and how it is installed.

What We Like!
  • The installation is simple, and you will not need any professionals for installation.
  • It comes with a 3-year warranty.
  • UV resistant gutter guard system.
Things to Consider!
  • It can shrink over time.

5. E-Z-Gutter Guard EZ-Quick | Best for Money Gutter Guards

Features at a glance
  • The product is simple to install without any screws or drilling work.
  • It features high-quality, expanded aluminum that won’t attract corrosion or rust.
  • Not suitable to use with plastic gutters.
  • The close-fitted mesh keeps its remains away and allows water to flow through.
  • The product is perfect to use in rough and extreme conditions.
  • Made in the USA

This gutter guard by E-Z features 4-foot sections. These sections are simple to install and quite lightweight yet durable enough to work effectively in all weather conditions.

This gutter mesh guard’s construction includes premium quality Aluminum that is highly durable and entirely resistant to rust and corrosion.

You will not find any plastic material in this gutter guard system because it is useful in extreme weather.

To make it durable and long-lasting, the aluminum is painted and also resistant to harmful UV rays. So it is equally effective for indoor and outdoor use.

The construction of this E-Z gutter guard is tension-engineered. Because of this unique construction and design, it snaps on the crucial points properly.

In terms of installation, this gutter guard system is effortless to install. And you will not require any drilling work or screws to snap it on the gutter.

What We Like!
  • The aluminum construction makes it durable and resistant to rust and corrosion.
  • The best gutter guard to use in rough weather.
  • Hassle-free and straightforward installation.
Things to Consider!
  • We found out that large leaves and pollen might get stuck in it; however, you can easily blow them off.

6. Gutter Cups Gutter Guards | Best Gutter Cover Protection

Features at a glance
  • Efficiently blocks all the debris, such as leaves, pine needles, and others, from clogging gutters.
  • Reliable protection and little gutter cleaning.
  • The included cups ensure a consistent flow of water even when filled.
  • It is suitable for all standard residential gutters.
  • It keeps your home safe from dirt and mold.

Our last but definitely not the least guard comes from Gutter Cups. It measures around 3.25 in diameter and 1.5 feet long.

It efficiently blocks all the debris and limits the cleaning frequency and damage to your home’s walls and foundation. The product is expertly designed and tested to prevent severe debris.

With these Gutter Cups Guards, you will not have to use a ladder to eliminate debris.

The installation is also incredibly effortless; just buy this gutter guard system and place it in your desired location. That’s all.

To operate, it features a multiple-barrier protection system and holed shell.

It keeps away all the leaves and other debris that portends to clog the gutter. In this way, the flow of water remains consistent and quick.

Lastly, this Gutter Cups guard is flexible, robust, and you will not need any special tools or clips for installation. You can also cut it according to your requirements.

What We Like!
  • It features a unique barrier protection system.
  • The holed outer shell offers a consistent flow of water.
  • The guard is entirely UV-protected.
  • The guard is perfect to use in all conditions.
Things to Consider!
  • Not that effective to block small debris.

7. A-M Aluminum | Corrsion Resistant Gutter Gaurds

Features at a glance
  • The guard is made of a heavy gauge of aluminum that will not rot or rust.
  • 25-years warranty.
  • It will not affect the look of your house because it is not visible from the ground.
  • It can efficiently handle rainstorms and debris with its 380 holes.
  • Easy to install a gutter guard.
  • Made in the USA.
A-M Aluminum gutter guard is perhaps the most good-looking gutter guard in the market.

Not only looks but its remarkable features are also the reason that we have included in this of the best gutter guards.

You can use these A-M aluminum gutter guards with hidden hangars, but if you have other hangars such as a K-style hangar, it is also compatible with that.

This guard’s construction is reliable and robust; it is constructed with high-quality aluminum resistant to rust and corrosion.

The installation is simple, and you can easily install it without acquiring the services of a technician.

But be careful during the installation of this gutter guard, especially if you are installing it for the first time, as it may affect the roof warranty if not done carefully.

The company backs its product by offering a twenty-five-year warranty so you can rest assure that you are covered.

The guard contains several holes that allow the water to flow into the gutters while blocking the debris from flowing into the gutters.

What We Like!
  • The guard is made of heavy gauge Aluminum.
  • It is ideal for both residential and industrial uses.
  • 25-Years Warranty.
  • Not visible from the ground.
Things to Consider!
  • These gutter guards are specifically made for all types of hangars.

8. Home Intuition Gutter Guard | Mesh Gutter Gaurds

Features at a glance
  • 6 x 20-inch Plastic Mesh Gutter Guard.
  • Blocks leaves and dirt from flowing into the gutters.
  • You can cut it as per your requirements.
  • Plastic construction is rust-resistant.
  • Works flawlessly for years.
Protect your gutter system with this affordable Home Intuition Plastic Mesh Gutter Guard system. It blocks all the leaves, dirt, and debris from entering and eventually choking your gutter.

The construction of this guard features high-quality and durable plastic material that is resistant to corrosion.

This Home Intuition Gutter Guard System protects the gutter from clogging and allows for a smooth, consistent rainwater flow.

It contains numerous holes that only block leaves and other debris from flowing into the gutter.

The gutter guard is virtually invisible, so in this way, it will not affect the look and layout of the gutters. The installation is simple, and you can do it yourself easily and quickly.

Installation can be done without screws; neither will you get any in the pack. It stays firm and can survive heavy downpours.

The gutters are highly robust and durable, and they are weather-resistant as well. The long-term warranty by the makers allows you to purchase it with confidence.

What We Like!
  • Powerful and sturdy gutter guard system.
  • Weather-resistant, so you can use it anywhere you want.
  • Perfect for roof gutters.
  • The guard system is simple to install.
Things to Consider!
  • According to some consumer reviews, it is suitable for scorching areas.

9. STEELCO 6-Mesh Galvanized | Best Gutter Guards for Metal Roofs

Features at a glance
  • Manufactured in the USA.
  • Suitable to use in heavy rains. It allows for a consistent flow of water and blocks debris.
  • It will not sag or bend like other cheap gutter guards.
  • Made from highly durable materials.
  • You can use it on your existing gutters.
SteelCo Mesh Galvanized gutter guard is a permanent and reliable solution to your gutter blocking problem.

It provides you with reliable protection by blocking any leaves or debris from flowing into the gutter while offering a maximum water flow during heavy rains.

The mesh guard is expertly designed to ensure that it does not lose its original shape throughout the process.

It will not get affected like other cheap gutter guards due to the change in weather.

The guard is available in both standard and custom shapes and sizes. You can also cut the guard as per your needs and requirements.

This also comes in handy if you are not sure about the size of your gutters.

The materials are highly durable, and the guard will not corrode or rust even if exposed to various weather elements such as air, rain, or moisture.

In simple words, you can use it anywhere you want. This Mesh galvanized gutter guard will work efficiently for many years.

What We Like!
  • The unit is rust and corrosion-resistant.
  • It can efficiently survive extreme weather conditions and rugged uses.
  • You can customize the Mesh as per your needs.
  • Will does not affect the flow of rainwater.
Things to Consider!
  • The installation is not simple, and you might need a professional to install this gutter guard.

10. LeafsOut Micro Mesh Rain Gutter Guard System

Features at a glance
  • You can easily install this gutter guard on several types of gutters and roofs as well.
  • The guard features stainless steel mesh that makes it highly durable.
  • Much better performance than plastic and foam guards.
  • The weight is around 5 pounds, easy to carry around.
LeafsOut micro mesh rain gutter guard features stainless steel construction; hence it is entirely resistant to rust and corrosion.

The thickness of the guard ad strength and light-weight makes it simple to carry.

Furthermore, the base of this LeafsOut micro-mesh guard is made of aluminum, so basically, it is stainless steel plus aluminum; hence we can say that the product is highly durable and reliable as well.

The design features micromesh siphon strips worldwide, which helps collect the water and the guard and break the surface tension.

Consequently, the water doesn’t pool on the surface, and no other debris will accumulate on guard. This will also help to prevent pests from forming their nest on the gutter.

The installation might be a little tricky, especially if you are installing it for the first time.

We would like to recommend opting for professional installers to get the best results.

Apart from this petty issue, this is the best gutter guard currently available in the market.

What We Like!
  • The quality of the product is top-notch.
  • Affordable gutter guard.
  • The stainless steel and aluminum construction offers reliability and makes it a durable gutter guard.
Things to Consider!
  • The installation of this gutter guard is complicated. You may have to cut or drill holes to fit this thing.

Buying Guide For Gutter Guards

Consider the following points when going to buy a gutter guard system.

1. Types of Gutter Guard Systems

Some common types of gutter guards available in the market that you can install are:

Metal Screens

Metal screen guards are made of steel and aluminum. These guards are simple to install. These guards are efficient for large debris but not that suitable to prevent finer particles.


You can install special sponge material on the gutter to keep the debris away from clogging the gutter.

But, you will have to dispose of the debris separately to avoid compost and mold. Furthermore, the sponge or foam is a flammable substance, so apply it with care.

Brush Inserts/Pipe Cleaner

These guards feature wire with long spikes, which allows you to clean the gutter easily.

With this gutter guard, the tiny particles of debris may still be left in sewerage, and another drawback of this gutter guard is that it is not that simple to clean or maintain the inserts.

Plastic Screens

It looks like a metal screen, but you can easily slide it into small areas where metal screens are difficult to slide.

The guard is efficient in protecting against large particles but not suitable for small debris and elements.

Slit Covers

All the debris is swept away on the edges in this guard, and it only allows water to flow through.

Proper and regular cleaning and maintenance of this gutter guard are required; it will not work adequately.

Reverse Curve

This gutter guard resembles slit covers and only lets water pass through, keeping the debris at the front border.

But this can also allow the pests to build their nests in the gutter or around it. Furthermore, the installation is tricky a bit as compared to other guards.

Micromesh Gutter Guards

These guards include a mesh with holes, and only water is allowed to flow through while every other thing will be blocked.

2. Animal Nest Prevention

When buying the gutter guard system, ensure that it doesn’t invite bugs and pests into the gutter to form their nests. The nests of insects and pests can severely affect the working of internal pipes or the roof.

3. Cleaning Mechanism

Purchasing a gutter guard that needs little maintenance and cleaning is always handy. So when buying, pick the one which doesn’t require too much maintenance and cleaning.

4. Durability

If your gutter cover is sturdy and durable, only then your gutter system will be resilient.

The main reason for buying a new gutter guard is to protect and cover the gutters; it is an investment that no one likes to make often. So ensure that you buy a durable and branded gutter guard.

5. Gutter Size

This one is quite obvious, but most people have issues with the gutter’s size and measurement.

So we will recommend taking an accurate measurement before purchasing your new gutter guard system, or else you will have to face the trouble. Eventually, you will end up wasting your precious time.

6. Weather Conditions

If you are residing in a state where the conditions are extreme such as hot conditions or snowfall, we would like to advise you to invest in a gutter cover that can endure harsh weather conditions.

Similarly, your area’s rainfall amount also plays a vital role in purchasing a new gutter cover. If your area experiences heavy rains throughout the year, you will have to go for the best gutter guard.

7. Care and Maintenance

The most important thing to mention in this section is that keep in mind that no gutter guard is maintenance-free.

Even the best gutter guards, as per customer reports, require cleaning. But in the best guard, you don’t have to perform the task regularly.

Look for gutter covers that require little maintenance. Despite this, ensure that the performance is not compromised by any means.

8. Ease of Use

It is highly recommended to opt for a guard that is straightforward to install. Otherwise, you will have to hire experts to do the work for you. But the installation of a gutter guard system is a simple DIY task.

The products that are mentioned in this list can be installed without any special tools. There are some gutter guards that you can install without screws.

related: best garbage disposals

9. Gutter Guard Video Guide

Final Verdict

In the end, the process of purchasing the best gutter guard can be a little confusing as there are so many products in the market, and everyone claims that it is the best.

We are hopeful that you will have any difficulty after going through our five best gutter guards’ consumer ratings & reports and other important considerations.

FAQs About Gutter Guards

Does Gutter Guard a Waste of Money?

Yes, it is if not installed properly. To get the maximum value for your money, make sure to understand the nature of debris you need to handle & the weather implications.

Are gutter guards a good idea?

Yes, it is a great idea to get a longer life for your gutters and avoid flooding your basements and lower areas.

How to remove gutter guards?

Normally the gutter guards have a lock/unlock system. You can easily remove it once installed.

More to Know about Gutter Guards…

It is highly recommended to check your gutters in the rainy season and fall, and summer.

You should also check out that snow and ice do not block gutters in winters. Spring and summer seasons have their own problems; it mostly depends on the leaves around your home.

Protecting your gutter area by inserting a gutter guard will keep all the dirt and muck away from your house, so there will be less cleaning work for you to do when the rain ends.

Most homeowners know the worth of the best gutter guards. For that reason, the best gutter guard’s consumer ratings & reports assist you in picking the perfect one that suits all your needs.

No one likes the filth in the gutters and on the roads. Sometimes, the smell of this filth and muck is so strong and unpleasant that it becomes difficult to breathe.

Now, the purchase of a gutter guard can be a hectic issue. But don’t worry; you can solve this by paying attention to the five best gutter guards’ consumer ratings & reports that we have compiled below in the post.

Go through it, and we are confident that you will get a better idea about which gutter guard suits your needs by the end. But before proceeding further, let’s quickly take a look at what the gutter guard is and the types of gutter guards.

related: trash compactor reviews

What is the perfect hole size for gutter guard mesh?

If the hole of the gutter mesh is too small, this will affect the drainage of water. Similarly, the gaps that are too big will not block the debris efficiently. Holes that are approximately 6 mm are suitable for the purpose.

Do Gutter Guards Really Work?

Well, they do work. Gutter covers or gutter covers are instrumental in keeping the gutters free and clear of all types of wreckage.

However, some are enhanced than others. The working of gutter guards also depends on how they are installed. If not installed correctly, none of them will work.

Do gutter guards cause problems?

Guards that allow the debris to enter and are made from cheap plastic are not recommended.

They often cause problems, and by looking at the gutter guard consumer guides, we can say that these result in damaged roof and systems.

How much cost do I need to pay to install the best gutter guards?

Typically you need to pay $3 to $20 per foot. It depends on many factors like;

  • Your location – Rainy & Stormy Areas
  • Warranty & Life
  • Corrosion Resistance
  • Customization
  • Building Design & Height
  • Maintenance Plans, etc

How often to do the maintenance of a Gutter Gaurd System?

Quarterly inspection and twice a year cleaning is recommended. Then it depends on where you reside and all that.

How to clean a gutter guard system?

You can buy a drone to do it for you. There are cleaning robots that are also available in the market.

If you are not that privileged, try to, but gutter guards with auto cleaning system bit costly initially but worthy in the longer run.

Should I go for an Aluminum or Stainless steel gutter guard system?

Stainless steel has high tensile strength that can hold a heavy load, and on the other hand, Aluminum is quite lightweight.

Now calculate your debris and overall load, including wet maple leaf, etc., to figure it out. I like the Raptor stainless steel micromesh system.

Why do my gutters drip?

If your gutters are blocked or choked or the water is overflowing, this might be the reason for leakage and drippings.

Do gutter guards work in heavy rain?

Yes, screen types of fixed gutter guards perform well, mainly in this scenario, as these are seamlessly adjusted and maintain the water flow without any hiccups.

What are the benefits of the Gutter Guard?

Some of the main benefits of the gutter guard system as per consumer ratings & reports are:

  • Protection from the natural elements
  • No blocks
  • Smooth flow of water
  • Less wear and tear
  • Fewer chances of cracks from snow or ice

Read More: Consumer Ratings & See all Blogs here

David Sullivan

12 thoughts on “10 Best Gutter Guards Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023”

    1. I will go with Gutter Helmet the reason is it will be less costly as you change the whole system in case of a leaf filter. On the other hand, a gutter helmet is adjusted in the already installed gutter guard system.

  1. I have the same question as one of these customers above. Did you review Leaf Filter or Gutter Helmet? The internet search keeps showing Leaf Filter as the #1 Company for gutter protection. However, I think it’s hype, but not sure. As consumers, it’s hard to know without investing and finding out later that it’s not true.

    1. I have not reviewed separately but I will go with Gutter Helmet on any day. Less costly and can be installed easily on your already installed gutter system.

  2. Are you familiar with Gutter Glove? How does that rate to you? Also, how does one evaluate whether the actual gutters need to be replaced or if just a new cover system will solve our problem of clogged gutters from leaves, pine needles and squirrel nests?

    1. I’m not a gutter professional, but we bought the Leaf Guard system about 8 years ago. We were impressed and looking forward to a lifetime of no gutter maintenance. LG works on the concept of water tension … water ‘sticks’ to the curved edge and goes into the gutter. Over time that curved edge builds up with dirt and interferes with the water adhesion. I have to clean that edge twice a year. Luckily we have a ranch so it’s within reach. Unfortunately our house is on a hill and drops down at least 20 feet at the back of the house making the rear gutters unreachable to clean. So if you don’t mind cleaning the edge of these gutters a few times a year, they work well.

  3. robert j. walters

    come on folks, you really DON’T need gutters at all … all that expense, all that maintenance, all that headache ’cause you still have to clean gutters with or without a gutter guard … put a 2 foot wide stone runway around your house or plant bushes around the perimeter , OR , spend your money giving your wife a better kitchen or a better renovated walk-in-closet !!!

  4. Kevin a Wheeland

    It is hard to read this as a full time gutter guard installer who has removed and installed everything on the market. The top one is great, the micro mesh. The second type works great if you have virtually no trees. If you have trees nearby the leaves back up. Trust me, I see it daily. Go with micro mesh.. whether raptor or leaf filter. I install Costco. After that use gutter helmet types. I have installed around 70 gutter helmet types and had 2 back up. That was due to pine needles. Changing to a larger downspout did the trick. Number 7 works pretty well too. Blessings and I hope this helps someone.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top