7 Best Mattress Topper Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023

A good night’s sleep is what everybody needs after a tiring day.

However, that same bed that you hope will give you a relaxing time can sometimes turn out to be a nightmare.

This happens when your mattress has worn out or not supporting your back properly anymore.

Replacing a mattress can be expensive, but there is a more affordable yet efficient solution to this problem.

And it is a mattress topper.

You might have heard related terms such as mattress pad or protector. However, a mattress topper is more on the comfort side.

A mattress topper not only adds to the comfort and support but also extends the life of your mattress.

In this post, I am going to review the 7 best mattress toppers according to consumer reports and reviews 2023. So without further ado, let’s get started.

Best Mattress Topper Consumer Reports

  1. Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
  2. LUCID 4 Inch Down Alternative and Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
  3. Best Price Mattress 4″ Memory Foam Mattress Topper
  4. Subrtex 4 Inch Gel-Infused Memory Foam Bed Mattress Topper
  5. Sweetnight Mattress Topper & Protector
  6. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR Firm Mattress Topper
  7. Linenspa 2 Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper

7 Best Mattress Topper Reviews

I have compiled a list of the 7 best mattress toppers based on consumer reports 2023.

1. Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Check Latest Price

Do you prefer to get rid of sleep heat and mild back pain? Then choose this Sleep Innovation dual layer mattress topper.

You must be wondering, why not just get a new mattress that has it all? However, that would be rather difficult and expensive.

A more practical alternative is to get a mattress topper that can offer all these features and protection to your mattress.

This mattress protector comprises dual layers of gel memory foam and quilted fiberfill that’s basically like a giant pillow.

The gel memory foam is responsible for the cooling effect and reducing back pain. And the fiberfill is responsible for lightness and comfiness.

The best thing about this product is the fiberfill cover that acts as an extra layer between you and the block of foam. It provides twice the comfort with the support from gel memory foam.

When it comes to comfort with convenience, this product won’t disappoint you. The inside of the cover consists of polyester fiberfill.

This means that it is easily washable in a machine. All you have to do is cover off and put it on a gentle cycle with mild detergent and cold water. When it comes to the foam layer, you can clean it with a damp cloth.

  • Dual-layer comfort
  • Good heat retention
  • Easily washable in the machine
  • Relieves pressure
  • It is hypoallergenic
  • Not firm enough

2. LUCID 4 Inch Down Alternative and Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Check Latest Price

You must be wondering why not just buy a new mattress and be done with it? Well, first of all, on average it would be more expensive to buy a new mattress than a mattress topper.

That’s right, a mattress topper with the right features and material will make you sleep like a baby.

Consider the LUCID 4-inch mattress topper that comes with two alternative layers—a 2-inch layer of gel memory foam for plushness and a 2-inch down-alternative for added comfort.

The memory foam is hypoallergenic, ventilated, and infused with gel. This allows the regulation of body temperature and support curves. It even allows you to sleep cooler.

Whereas the portion with the down-alternative layer adds the premium comfort factor to the topper. It adds an airy and light layer of padding to the mattress. It is dryer safe and washable as it is made up of 100% cotton.

One of the reasons people get disappointed with mattress covers and toppers is that they don’t fit very well.

However, that is not at all the case for a LUCID mattress topper. It consists of a fitted sheet style design. This secures and ensures that the memory foam fits comfortably.

  • Gel-infused hypoallergenic memory foam
  • Light and airy feel with down-alternative padding.
  • Regulated body temperature
  • Eliminates pressure points
  • Dryer safe and washable
  • A little too soft

3. Best Price Mattress 4″ Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Check Latest Price

Sometimes an upgrade to your furniture can do wonders. This also includes personalizing and making your bed comfortable.

An affordable way to do so is to get a quality mattress topper. That’s right; a mattress topper is all the latest trends in enhancing your sleeping experience.

Take a look at this Best Price memory foam mattress. It consists of layers of 2.5-inch high-density base foam and 1.5-inch memory foam. This means that you get to enjoy a real pressure-relieving sleep.

It allows you to have a heat-free sleep as the foam actively cradles the curves of your body. This allows you to lie smoothly without sinking too much and relieves pressure points as well.

The memory foam’s unique thing is that its secret ingredient is Green Tea Extract. That’s right! The memory foam layer is infused with green tea extract for a few reasons.

One of them is the reduction of stress due to the agents present in the green tea extract.

Preserving this mattress topper is also easy. Not only is it hand-washable, but it also comes with a zippered cover. It is made of a polyester mesh that feels plush.

  • Eliminates pressure points
  • Memory foam infused with green tea extracts
  • Hand-washable
  • Zippered cover included
  • 5-year warranty
  • Not sheet-style fitted

4. Subrtex 4 Inch Gel-Infused Memory Foam Bed Mattress Topper

It’s never been easier to prolong your mattress’s life. Not just that, but save money and get better sleep. You get all this with just a single mattress topper.

However, not just any mattress topper but the upgraded gel-infused Subrtex memory foam mattress topper.

Memory foam has changed our sleeping experience for good. They not only help with sleep heat but also relaxes the joints and muscles for a relaxing slumber.

This particular mattress topper consists of a ventilated gel-infused memory foam that regulates sleeping temperature. Its design also supports good airflow that we all need to get rid of sleep heat.

Another great feature that you’ll love is the bamboo cover. Most people complain that their mattress cover shifts a lot while sleeping.

That is why to eliminate this problem; there is anti-slip mesh backing in the bamboo cover that prevents sliding. Moreover, you can easily remove and wash the cover with the help of a metal zipper.

The memory foam offers the same pressure-relieving and breathable sleeping experience as other memory foam mattress toppers.

Something different about this one is that it guarantees longevity. This is because this mattress topper uses 3.5-pound density memory foam. This ensures the protection of your mattress.

  • Removable and washable bamboo cover
  • Gel-infused memory foam
  • No harmful phthalates or synthetic latex are used.
  • Improves sleep quality
  • Four adjustable straps
  • It is a little too soft

5. Sweetnight Mattress Topper & Protector

Are you looking for a convenient yet affordable upgrade to your mattress? How about trying the plush 3-inch SweetNight mattress topper?

You must be wondering how a mattress topper adds to the comfort and softness of the mattress.

The topper’s recipe consists of Ingredients such as ventilated memory foam with bamboo charcoal and cooling gel.

This not only adds to the plushness and comfort of the mattress but also provides firm support.

You can feel the pressure points being relieved as the toppers conform to your body’s curves. It will not immediately sink, so you wouldn’t have to worry about backaches.

The special memory foam makes it possible to achieve a perfect combination of firmness and softness.

Moreover, you wouldn’t even need to worry about the foam getting spoiled. The mattress topper comes along with a washable and removable zippered cover that protects the foam.

If you prefer comfort with protection, then mattress toppers should be your first choice.

Its revolutionary design is not only waterproof but noiseless as well. The innovative bamboo fiber surface gives protection against spills, dust mites, perspirations, and other fluids.

This premium noiseless mattress topper is incredibly versatile. It can fit on almost all types and sizes of mattresses with four-bed sheet holder straps.

  • Conforms to body curves to alleviate pressure points
  • Protection against dust mites and allergens
  • Waterproof
  • Gel-infused memory foam
  • Moisture absorption
  • Egg crate design
  •  A little too firm

6. Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR Firm Mattress Topper

There are many reasons that could lead to discomfort while sleeping. It can be due to injury or insomnia or it can be sometimes the mattress.

A worn-out mattress can cause as much discomfort as a stiff back. That is why quality mattress toppers like this one are a preferred option by many.

Belonging to a reputable company, you can expect all the basic benefits from the Tempur mattress topper.

The first thing that you’ll notice is the full 3-inch thickness that gives a very plush feel overall. It is made up of a patented Tempur foam. It is the company’s specially designed memory foam.

This Tempur material gives real comfort with its pressure-relieving properties. It provides a perfect blend of plushness and supportiveness.

The mattress topper doesn’t sink immediately when weight is applied. It has a slow response, which means you won’t sink into it.

The topper’s material is said to have a personalized and precise response to your body’s shape, weight, and temperature.

Other key features you might be interested in are the cover’s washability and durability. This machine-washable mattress topper doesn’t let dust mites or other allergens to stay in.

The mattress topper is encased in a knit-polyester blend. This makes it moisture-wicking and breathable with a nice stretch to it.

  • Made of unique patented Tempur foam
  • Extra plush and comfortable
  • Moisture-wicking and breathable
  • Washable cover
  • 3-inch memory foam
  • Tendency of retaining heat

7. Linenspa 2 Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Another great product that gives you comfort and enhanced sleeping experience.

The Lines mattress topper comes with a 2-inch gel memory foam. This is perfect for people looking for something ultra-plush. However, it does conform to your body curves to make you feel more supportive.

Apart from alleviating all those much-needed pressure points, the gel memory foam also regulates the temperature.

The memory foam is infused with temperature-regulating gel beads. They help in dissipating body heat so that you don’t feel like you are in a sauna.

When it comes to comfort plus support, this mattress protector is a winner. It only has a plush feel but also evenly distributes your weight. This helps in aligning your spine.

2-in memory foam not cutting it for you? No worries, you can try the 3-inch profile as well. This mattress protector not only revitalizes your old mattress but also gives you the choice of choosing the perfect one for you.

One other great thing about this mattress topper is its durability. It can withstand wear and tear to give your mattress life a shot in the long-term.

  • Regulates surface temperature
  • Prevents long term wear
  • Super soft and comfy
  • Relieves pressure points
  • 3-year warranty
  • It is extremely soft and plush

How To Choose The Best Mattress Topper

Type of Mattress Topper

Mattress toppers are an affordable alternative to getting an expensive new mattress. Not only is it about money but also your sleeping preferences.

If your current mattress cannot give you the comfort you need, then why not get something that can give you all?

Mattress toppers come in various sizes, materials, and features. You can decide through a series of features regarding which one suits you best.

In this section, I have listed a few helpful features and information that can give you a clearer idea of why the type of mattress topper is right for you.

Mattress topper or Protector?

You might have heard terms like mattress topper or mattress protector. Each of these items is different and serves different purposes.

However, if you are looking to add comfort with ample support to your body, then a mattress topper is a great option.

You wouldn’t even need to replace your mattress and, at the same time, improve its quality.

A topper basically consists of thick layers of different material that adds to the comfort of the body. It improves the plushness and sleeping experience.

Density and Thickness

One of the most important features you need to look out for. Generally, toppers fall between the range of two- and eight-inch thickness.

The thicker the mattress, the better it can support your weight. However, keep in mind that thick mattress toppers tend to become very hot.

It’s best to select from a range of gel-infused memory foams that are heat dissipators. A thick mattress topper also helps to revitalize aging mattresses.

Reducing body heat and noise

You won’t be getting a new mattress topper if it doesn’t do anything for the body heat.

Now, brands use different materials to counter both these problems. If you choose latex or memory foam mattress toppers, they are good at reducing movement transmission.

However, they are terrible at regulating body temperature. The thicker they are, the hotter you feel.

For body heat, the best toppers are the ones consisting of feathers, wool, or down. They are a good choice for all-year-round use.


One of the most common reasons for buying a mattress topper is that your current mattress starts to feel stiff and uneven.

Every person’s definition of comfort differs from the other. If you want something that perfectly fits your body, then latex or memory foam should be your go-to product.

But if you prefer naturally soft material and plushness, you can either try down or cotton or low-density memory foam topper.


Many people can’t live without cleaning almost everything they have. This also counts the mattress topper.

Most mattress topper brands claim their product is machine-washable as well as dryer-friendly.

You need to read the manual carefully to remove the cover and then how to wash it properly.

Final Verdict

A well relaxed and fresh body can perform more efficiently in every race of life. And this can only be achieved with proper sleep.

Your mattress plays a vital role in this factor, and so does the mattress topper. So buy one that can address the arising issues of your mattress.

I adopted the one with a trusted name Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR Firm Mattress Topper and impro of my worn-out matt conditions. I easily wash it, and its plush feeling allows for a comfortable time.

Get your mattress topper to improve your health and energy more than before.

FAQs about Mattress Toppers

How do I know which thickness is best for me?

Mattress toppers come in a variety of thicknesses from 2-inches to 8-inches. Which thickness you should get depends on your sleep preferences.

However, generally, a thickness of three-inches is considered perfect on average in softness and support.

If you want extra support and plushness, you can opt for thicker mattress toppers.

Is a latex mattress topper a good option?

Latex or memory foam mattress toppers are popular choices with outstanding results.

When it comes to softness with support, latex mattress toppers give you many benefits. It doesn’t let your body sink but conforms to your body’s curves.

However, looking for something cooler than latex might not be a good option; they are not good at regulating body heat.

What type of firmness should I look for?

Memory foam mattress toppers have different numbers for density and firmness. Most people want a firm mattress topper because their current mattress has become a big lump.

The firmness number will be low if the topper is really soft while reaching a rating of up to 20.

When it comes to an average number, then 12 is considered medium-soft, and most people prefer that.

Will my mattress topper give me a cooling effect all night? 

Mattress toppers aren’t completely body-heat proof, but they do work to some extent.

The difference is because of the material used. If you have a thick memory foam or latex mattress topper, it would be hard to feel cool. They are not good at regulating body temperature.

On the other hand, if you go for cotton or down fiberfill, they are somewhat better at giving a good cooling effect.

Alex Mitchell

1 thought on “7 Best Mattress Topper Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023”

  1. Hi, after reading all consumer guide ratings, I did not see any suggestions as to wanting a twin size mattress topper for a kingsize bed. We have a patient who only weighs 78lbs. She is in Hospice Care and is experiencing hip pain due to her weight loss. She does not want to change beds. Her bed is kingsize. Is there any possibility that a smaller size topper would work on a kingsize bed? Sucurring the topper would be a challenge, but could it be done? Thank you for your site it was very helpful.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top