7 Best Crib Mattress Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023

Infants spend most of their time on a mattress, so if you feel overwhelmed while picking the best crib mattress, I understand.

As a parent, you can’t afford to make a mistake. Picking the wrong mattress means adding discomfort to the life of your munchkin, and you would never want that. Would you?

Organic mattresses are expensive, but they give you peace of mind that your baby is resting in a chemical-free space.

The innerspring mattress is the second-best choice for getting maximum support with optimal airflow. However, tons of foam mattresses align with your budget and baby’s requirements.

The mattress market is flooded with features, design, style, and price range. But Sweat not, I’m here with my detailed buying guide that helps you shop a perfect mattress for your crib.

I’m not talking about a best-fit product; I’m talking about all factors like body support, breathability, and firmness that make any crib a comfy haven for your sweetheart.

I’m sharing the list of top crib mattresses. This list includes an award-winning mattress that most parents and pediatricians recommend to other parents.

So without further ado here are the 7 best crib mattresses according to consumer ratings and reports in 2023.

Quick Picks

Here are the top-rated products we picked out that you would be interested in, depending on your budget…

Best Crib Mattress Consumer Ratings & Reports

  1. Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress CertiPUR-US Certified
  2. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
  3. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Dual Sided Toddler Mattress
  4. Safety 1st High-Density Thermo Crib Mattress
  5. Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress – Classic 150 Coil
  6. Babyletto Mattress with Water-Resistant Cover
  7. Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress

7 Best Crib Mattress Reviews 2023

I have compiled a list of the 7 best crib mattresses based on consumer ratings and reports 2023.

1. Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Mattress CertiPUR-US Certified

Features at a glance
  • Easy to Clean
  • Breathable foam core
  • Super Comfortable
  • CertiPUR-US Certified

You can’t set an ordinary mattress on a crib. You need something extraordinary like this JPMA certified Graco-Premium-Toddler-Mattress-White.

The first reason that will convince you to prefer the GRACO Crib mattress over other types is that it is an AWARD Winning Mattress.

It has won this Women’s Choice Awards in 2020 and 2021. 9 out of 10 customers recommend it.

Parents can rely on this mattress because it has a Parent Tested Parent Approved Seal. It means it gets approval for its quality and performance from other parents.

It also won another National Parent Product award. It won the third award from the 2021 JPMA Innovation award for the “Tried and True” category.

Apart from all the awards, its features are real deals. The first benefit of getting this crib mattress is that it will fit first on a full-size crib, and once your baby turns into a toddler, you can flip it to a firm side. And it will become a comfy toddler mattress.

This mattress is highly breathable to prevent suffocation risks. It is designed with a breathable firm-core.

There are two certifications to boost up customers’ trust in GRACO products. It’s GREENGUARDGold Certified. What does it mean?

This product screened for 10K chemicals and VOCs and successfully passed this test. It won’t pollute the air at any level.

Another certification is from CertiPUR-US, which gives parents peace of mind that this mattress is free of ozone depleters, mercury, lead, formaldehyde, and other heavy metals.

When it comes to maintaining hygiene, you can put it in a washing machine for a quick wash. Cleaning this mattress is a breeze in a challenging parenting lifestyle.

What We Like!
  • GREENGUARD Gold certified
  • Award-winning mattress
  • Grow with your kid
  • Removable outer cover
  • Water-Resistant
Things to Consider!
  • It is very firm.

2. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed

Features at a glance
  • Breathe-Thru Technology
  • WOVENAIRE Comfort
  • Natural Viscose Cover
  • Easy to Wash

Do you need a crib mattress recommended by Pediatricians? Look no further as NEWTON Crib mattress is the best choice one can make.

It is a safe mattress for kids. The manufacturer created it with Innovative Breathe-Thru Technology, so your munchkin can breathe right all the time. Its 100 percent breathability reduces the risk of suffocation and CO2 rebreathing.

When searching for a crib mattress with optimal breathability, you find Newton is better than an organic mattress.

All thanks to WovenAire Comfort technology, this mattress brings 90 percent air with 10 percent food grade. So, you can expect a good amount of breathability.

You won’t have to spend hours cleaning as it is 100 percent machine washable from cover to cover. Once you are done using it, recycle it to save the environment and its resources.

It offers a beautiful blend of comfort, support, and optimal air circulation, so your baby feels comfortable and cozy all the time.

This crib mattress is designed for stage 2. It is firm enough to support your baby’s body while soft enough to cradle him.

It is a tried and tested mattress that parents recommend to other parents with confidence. It will keep your baby comfy while letting him sleep well.

This GREENGUARD GOLD CERTIFIED product is free of foam, glue, latex, or springs. It has won Mom’s Choice Awards due to its outstanding performance and durability.

What We Like!
  • Durable
  • Easy to Remove cover
  • Comfortable and Firm
Things to Consider!
  • The mattress cover is 100% polyester

3. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Dual Sided Toddler Mattress

Features at a glance
  • Limited 7-year warranty
  • Environment-Friendly Design
  • Durable- Dual Side
  • Made in the USA

Conscious parents remained concerned about the safety of their kids. So, if you are looking for a safe to use crib mattress, it comes from Delta.

This super-affordable mattress is free from harmful chemicals and materials. Thereby, you have peace of mind that your baby is sleeping in a safe environment (free of toxic material).

The material of this crib mattress is sourced firm fiber core made from upcycled plastic bottles. You are making an environment-friendly move by getting this mattress.

It ensures a healthier and longer sleep for your toddlers and babies. This product perfectly fits a toddler bed and crib and won’t give you any hard time.

As far as cleaning is concerned, a waterproof vinyl cover makes parents’ lives pretty much more effortless. Both sides are usable for long-lasting use, and they are waterproof for easy cleaning.

The main selling point of this cost-effective crib mattress is its GREENGUARD Gold certification. It is inflammable since it doesn’t have any toxic fire retardants. Besides, it passed phthalate and CPSIA tests successfully.

Handling this crib mattress is super easy, all thanks to its lightweight design; changing a regular sheet won’t be a muscle hurting experience for parents.

What We Like!
  • Ideal for infant and toddler
  • GreenGuard Gold Certified
  • waterproof vinyl cover
  • Easy to Clean
Things to Consider!
  • It is too firm to use.

4. Safety 1st High-Density Thermo Crib Mattress

Features at a glance
  • Dual firmness
  • 10-year limited warranty
  • GREENGUARD GOLD Certification
  • Lightweight

Prioritizing the safety of a kid is the ultimate goal of a parent. When you have safety concerns, simply go with a SAFETY 1st crib mattress.

Safety 1st is America’s Most Recommended brand for baby cribs and mattresses. It also won the women’s Choice award due to top ratings.

You can set this mattress without thinking twice into a crib because it won’t emit any harmful chemicals in the indoor air. The proof comes in the form of GREENGUARD GOLD Certification.

Manufacturers use a high-density thermo-bonded fiber core, so your baby gets all the support you need.

It’s Vinyl outer cover is straightforward to clean. You can use a wipe to make it fresh all over again. This lightweight mattress makes the sheet cleaning task very simple.

Every mattress is handcrafted in Canada and made of imported textiles. If you want to make the most of its firmness and comfort, you need to rotate the mattress every two to three months.

This mattress is designed with dual-firmness. One side is extremely firm and suitable for infants. Another side is less firm yet comfy to offer excellent cushioning to toddlers.

What We Like!
  • Outstanding Support
  • Durable
  • Washable Vinyl Cover
  • Water-Resistant
Things to Consider!
  • The cover is not durable.

5. Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress – Classic 150 Coil

Features at a glance
  • 100% Cotton and Sugarcane
  • Made in the USA
  • Best Organic Crib Mattress
  • Breathable

If you are the kind of parent who can’t compromise on quality and wants nothing but the best for their kids, you should get an organic mattress from Naturepedic.

This brand is made of healthy domestic and imported fabric components. The goal of this brand is to eliminate toxicity from bedding and mattress.

It is made from organic cotton with a sugarcane coating. The purpose of adding a waterproof surface is to offer your sweetheart a very hygienic environment to breathe in.

Overnight urine incidents, daytime spit-ups, and other messes won’t affect the quality of this crib mattress. All thanks to its waterproof surface and sealed seam, no liquid or mess will find a way inside it.

This crib mattress is free of glues, adhesives, flame retardant, water repellent chemicals, etc. Parents feel good after purchasing this product because they know that they are investing money into a safe product.

100 percent cotton is used to ensure breathability while it is designed with a heavy-duty innerspring core, so your body gets strong edge support. This mattress is quite suitable for infants and heavy toddlers with weights up to 19 lbs.

It is a 100% GOTS-certified mattress that meets and exceeds all government flammability requirements.

This mattress has 2-stage firmness, where one firm side is designed to bring comfort and support to infants while a medium-firm side caters to the needs of toddlers.

What We Like!
  • 2-Stage firmness
  • Patented Waterproof Coating
  • 150-Coil InnerSpring for support
  • Ideal for heavy toddlers
Things to Consider!
  • Material is noisy.

6. Babyletto Mattress with Water-Resistant Cover

Features at a glance
  • No chemical smell
  • 2-Stage Firmness
  • Optimal breathability
  • Good support

Late-night urine accidents are always annoying and unhealthy for your baby. It may lead to a bacterial infection on your mattress. In that scenario, this dry waterproof mattress from Babyletto helps parents sleep at night without any concern.

The cover of this well-designed mattress is dry waterproof. Whether it’s liquid spill or urine incidents, your baby mattress will remain protected against all.

A soft cotton face crib mattress ensures comfort for your baby. This skin-friendly mattress is quite breathable. It reduces suffocation risks and helps parents take a sigh of relief.

The softcover is PVC-free, so it keeps moisture out and doesn’t let any liquid get into the foam due to the elasticated seam. You can remove its cover for a quick wash when it comes to cleaning.

There is a 2-stage dual-sided mattress where the firm side is super supportive for babies, while you can flip to the soft side to bring comfort for your toddler.

This mattress is safe to use as it meets all the flammability requirements imposed by the government.

It is made of 100% recyclable polyester core free of flame retardants, polyurethane, soy foam, vinyl (PVC), PFC’s, synthetic latex, or dyes.

What We Like!
  • Washable cover
  • Fit perfectly with standard crib
  • Waterproof removable cover
Things to Consider!
  • Mattress dents very quickly.

7. Lullaby Earth Breathe Safe 2-Stage Breathable Crib Mattress

Features at a glance
  • Firm Edges
  • Snug Fit, lightweight
  • Easy to Clean
  • 2-stage firmness

Babies should sleep on their back, but once they turn the side and sleep on their face, you need to get a high breathability mattress to prevent suffocation risks and ensure comfort and support side by side.

In that case, nothing works better than a Lullaby Earth breathable crib mattress. This mattress provides 97% more air while breathing from the sleep surfaces than a traditional mattress.

The brand offers practical hygiene without compromising overall quality, performance, and mattress hygiene.

Once your baby sleeps on this mattress, his body temperature will be regulated to prevent overheating scenarios.

Many parents hesitate to buy a crib mattress due to high breathability risks. If that’s what is in your mind, you need to know that the Lullaby mattress has passed an independent test and shows the lowest level of risk than its competitors.

This optimal breathability is maintained through a 3-dimensional fabric that lets air pass and circulates under the baby 360°.

There is a washable pad over a breathable surface. This cover is removable and keeps the mattress dry and well protected from spit-up, urine, and other kinds of messes.

If an accident happens, you can replace its pad quickly to bring comfort to your sweetheart.

The Lullaby Earth mattress is designed with a firm flat surface and strong edge support for your munchkin. The waterproof design reduces the risk of bacterial and mold growth.

This mattress is free of polyurethane foam, questionable materials such as) formaldehyde, vinyl, PVC, phthalates, perfluorinated compounds (PFCsand more.

Your baby needs excellent support with safety that is provided by Lullaby earth. The manufacturer used WaveSupport design to give optimal support to the soft body of your sweetheart.

Parents feel easy and comfortable as they have to deal with a practical design. When maintaining hygiene, simply remove its waterproof cover for laundry.

What We Like!
  • Washable, waterproof cover
  • No flammable material
  • Reduce breathability risks
  • Strong Structural support
Things to Consider!
  • Mattress Sag after two years.

Buying Guide For Crib Mattress

If a crib mattress looks cute, it doesn’t mean it will be highly functional. New parents make the mistake of getting a mattress. Your baby will spend 18 hours of his day on this mattress.

So, you can’t afford to make a mistake. I know parenthood means having a lot on your plate. I’m here to share the best crib mattress buying guide. Unlock all the factors you need to look into before purchasing a crib mattress.

Type of Mattress

In the market, you can find two types. One is Foam and the second is innerspring. The foam mattress is affordable but not as breathable as innerspring is  to avoid this mistake readily by checking a guide

Innerspring is quite a favorite among mattresses because it has standard layers that cushion the infant body. You need to get multiple layers of solid material with border rods. Try getting an innerspring mattress with a corner protector and steel clips.

The reason for going with this mattress is that it is quite durable. Also, look for a mattress with hypoallergenic cushioning so you make peace with the fact that it won’t cause any skin allergy for your sweetie.

Foam – Another option for a mattress is to get a high-density polyurethane foam. The best thing about mattresses is that they are lightweight. Parents feel very comfy with this specific kind of mattress.

Changing sheets and moving the crib around becomes pretty convenient. But the quality of support from foam mattresses is not as amazing as you have with innerspring.

Related: Best mattress for heavy person


Always check for the fitness level of a mattress. You need good firmness in a mattress so that it can provide the best back and body support to your infant.

If a mattress is very soft, it will hug your baby and boost the risk of SIDS. However, don’t get a too firm mattress as they may not offer a good night’s sleep to your cutie.


You need to keep your baby clean to maintain a hygienic environment, which is vital for the health and growth of your baby. So, always get a mattress that is designed with a removable cover.

Getting a water-resistant cover seems like a good idea. Urine and spit-up incidents are unavoidable with kids, so having an easy-to-clean mattress is one way to deal with this issue.

Some brands offer washable mattresses and foam. Instead of washing it with your hands, you would be able to do the laundry independently.


The most crucial factor to consider in a crib mattress is breathability. Although kids sleep on their back most of the time, their face turns toward the mattress once they take it aside.

If a mattress isn’t breathable, SIDS risk increases significantly. Sudden Infant Death Syndrome is a thing you can’t afford to ignore.


Organic mattresses are your ultimate choice if you don’t like inorganic material-made mattresses. This mattress brings more cushioning and support.

Since manufacturers use top-quality material to create this mattress, you need to pay extra money for that. Before you get this kind of mattress, you should know that the covers of these mattresses aren’t waterproof.

Therefore, you should get a washable, removable, and water-resistant cover to have a peaceful sleep for you and your baby at night.


It’s good to set a budget and then stick to it. High price mattresses usually have more features than low price ones.

But you need to ask yourself whether paying extra money is worth it or not. Safety features such as non-inflammable material and certifications are something you should pay money for.

Final Verdict

When shopping for the best crib mattress, you need to settle for a product that offers a good combination of comfort, quality, and firmness.

Thankfully, you can get a mattress within your budget range. While shopping for the best baby mattresses, the price might not be the main factor to look into, but my buying guide will direct you to other vital considerations.

Since parents need to grab a lot of things for their sweeties simultaneously, if you are already handling a lot, then save your time by reading detailed reviews of the seven best mattresses. This reading will direct you toward your ultimate choice for sure.

FAQs About Crib Mattress

Should I purchase a used crib mattress?

You shouldn’t, and it poses severe health and hygiene risks for your baby. A used mattress has dip and sagginess due to improper storage and regular use.

If you use the same mattress for your baby, lack of firmness doesn’t support his body’s contour. It may increase the risk of sudden infant death syndrome.

Do all crib mattresses fit all cribs?

The simple answer is NO. You should try purchasing a crib mattress with at least 52x28x4 inches so that it becomes compatible with modern-day cribs.

If a mattress doesn’t fit well, it will increase the gap between the mattress and crib edge, which increases the danger for your sleeping baby.

What is the difference between a mattress for a baby and a toddler?

There is not much difference in terms of the size and material of a mattress. You can buy one and use it for both growth stages.

However, you need to get a mattress that has dual-stage firmness. A high firm side is good for infants, while a medium firm is suitable for toddlers.

How often should you replace a crib mattress?

You should replace a crib mattress after five years. Although many mattresses come with a 10-year warranty, you should use them for less than five years if it’s not well-maintained and properly cared for.

When can a baby use the toddler side of a mattress?

You can turn the side when your baby is one year old. If you are not sure, it’s better to consult with your pediatrician.

Alex Mitchell

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top