10 Best Mascara Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023

Mascaras are an important part of anyone’s makeup beauty routine. It accentuates the natural lash line and gives you fuller and longer lashes without fake lashes.

Since they’re used on your natural lashes, these are not heavy to handle; they don’t weigh your eyes down or look very eccentric.

Besides giving you longer natural lashes, these also help you merge your fake lashes to your real lashes, a smooth transition.

10 Best Mascara Consumer Ratings & Reports

I have compiled a list of the top-rated available in the market to make things hassle-free for you.

1. Bobbi Brown 2 Pc Lashes On The Double Smokey Eye Mascara Set

Check Latest Price

Do you want something to enhance your lashes? Are you looking for a high-quality curling mascara? Well, Bobby brown is a world renowned company for manufacturing makeup products. This mascara set y Bobby Brown is no doubt an incredible mascara. It is black and long lasting. You won’t have to worry about redoing it again and again.

What We Like!
  • Long lasting curling mascara
  • Waterproof
Things to Consider!
  • A little expensive

2. Buxom Lash Waterproof Volumizing Mascara

Check Latest Price

Well, in case you need a mascara that is volumizing and long lasting, this Buxom mascara is the best option. It is a long lasting mascara that will enhance the length of your lashes and make it look fuller and better. It will enhance your features and this waterproof mascara will definitely be a huge hit.

What We Like!
  • Waterproof mascara
  • Volumizing mascara for fuller lashes.
Things to Consider!
  • Not the easiest to apply

3. Honest beauty 2-in-1 lash length, volume, definition mascara

Check Latest Price

Having something which is endorsed clinically and proven by dermatologists makes the product even more trustworthy. And when it’s made with proper and open ingredients, the whole thing is appreciated by anyone who uses it.

Just like these properties, the Honest beauty lash primer and mascara are made to make things simple. This lash primer forms a base for the user to have an even application. The primer helps in letting the mascara stay for a longer time. And creates a much stable and separated eyelash base for the mascara to work on and not clump up.

This product is made without additives, which may irritate some and are considered disliked in the beauty industry. A cruelty-free product that has a unanimous vote on having a dramatic effect on the lashes.

What We Like!
  • Gives a great and natural lash lift.
  • Clinically tested and proven to work.
  • Multiple surveys show that the customers agree with the mascara giving great outcomes.
Things to Consider!
  • Expensive.

4. L’Oreal Paris makes up voluminous Original Volume Building Mascara

This voluminous mascara is an effective and easy mascara to apply. There are six total colors available and which are preferred for any bold look. All 6 have the same consistency and can be applied very easily with a sleek application brush.

The formula of the mascara prevents it from clumping and keeps the lashes naturally soft. The brush evenly applicants the lashes that do not make them look fake and sustains a bold lash look.

The mascara treats every lash individually and has a very natural and beautiful outlook. When properly applied, this entire mascara can give the lash an uplift of 5x the original thickness.

This mascara should not be confused with the property mascaras, which lift the lashes to a longer length; this makes the lashes much thicker and volume to show their existence.

What We Like!
  • Great for people with thin eyelashes.
  • Gives extreme volume.
  • A non-clumpy formula.
Things to Consider!
  • This mascara is not for people with sensitive skin.
  • The packaging may also differ from what is actually seen in pictures.

5. Shutterlash Mascara Black Noir

This last one on the list is the perfect option for all those who need something easy to apply. The brush it comes with is super simple to use.

The super sleek bottle and the amazing packaging are the other incredible features of this mascara. It is a waterproof mascara that is worth a try.

What We Like!
  • Super simple and easy application
  • Long lasting and waterproof
Things to Consider!
  • Nothing to mention

6. Essence lash Princess False lash Effect Mascara

Do you support gluten and cruelty-free products that definitely live up to their name? This mascara is the one for you. With a good property of lifting lashing and giving a voluminous look and making your lashes look bold and pretty. This mascara helps in maintaining a good eyelash look for the entire day. Not only does it last long, but it has a straightforward application.

Just with 2-3 strokes of your brush, you can feel a huge difference in what your eyelashes are and what they were before. The main idea of this mascara is to omit the use of falsies. This makes your lashes longer and prettier without any clumping; your lashes wouldn’t need any extra help to keep them looking fabulous all day long.

The applicator brush is the classic fiber brush, which treats every strand of hair individually, making it non-clumpy and smooth throughout. This same set has four more options to choose from. They are extremely affordable, making it easier for you to buy them all instead of resisting and only choosing one. The result of all of these is amazing.

What We Like!
  • Easy lash life effect.
  • The lashes look natural and very heavy without using false lashes.
  • The mascara is extremely affordable.
Things to Consider!
  • Better when applied properly. Some customers have issues with the outcome when applied.

7. Vivienne Sabó- Classical french mascara cabaret

Made with the absolute best to provide its customers with the utmost performance. This mascara helps in uplifting your eyelashes and brings them to a longer and much thicker consistency.

This mascara does not clump up and make your eyelashes heavy or very clumpy. It has an extremely smooth application that allows the user to stay pretty with long lashes all day long. They don’t wear down throughout the day, and now the company also has a new mascara, which is waterproof.

This mascara is known to be smudge-proof and does not make your eyes look like a raccoon’s, and you can stay and look fresh all day long. Your natural lashes need all the protection they can get and to support this.

The mascara is made to protect your natural las line and not be too damaging so that you can wear your mascara all day long and every day without being worried about your lashes falling off.

What We Like!
  • Cruelty-free
  • Smudge-proof and extremely lightweight.
  • Enhances your natural lash line.
Things to Consider!
  • It does not have worldwide shipping.

8. Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Washable Mascara.

Maybelline is known to be the best drug store makeup brand almost everywhere. This makeup brand has created a few of the best makeup products that are used worldwide and are loved by every woman who uses them. Just as so, they haven’t held back when it comes to creating amazing mascaras.

This mascara gives you an amazing lash lift and makes them voluminous with every use. The bristles in the brush of this mascara are absolutely amazing. With ten layers of individual bristles, this treats every individual strand of your eyelash and coats evenly with mascara to help them be much more volumized. This mascara has the most versatile brush bristle, which works with eyelashes, either short or long.

The mascara is crafted with care to ensure it does not react with people who wear contact lenses and has a great formula that does not clump up and give mural long lashes. This mascara has a great hold on your lashes and is waterproof. The mascara does not get off easily with micellar water.

What We Like!
  • Waterproof
  • Great with people who wear contacts.
  • Easy application and long term wear.
Things to Consider!
  • It does not come off with water that needs the help of micellar water.

9. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Makeup Lash Paradise Mascara

L’Oreal has introduced a great mascara, which helps in building great lashes for all-day wear. This is more of a set that can be paired with multiple products to produce a great all face makeup look. The mascara helps in making the lashes longer and has a great brush to accompany its claim.

This mascara brush has around 200 bristles that separate your lashes and make them the much least clumpy deal of work. It keeps your natural eyelashes soft and very easy to manage while giving them an uplift. The usage of your personal multi bristle brush gives a great non-flaky application. The feathered eyelashes give you a great opportunity to ditch the falsies and use your natural lashes to make an impact.

Overall a great mascara for personal usage; is not very suggested for the user to share their mascara with multiple others since it may cause irritation or bacteria transfer for the initial owner.

What We Like!
  • Good for volume induction.
  • Easy application.
  • Individual lash application.
Things to Consider!
  • Not intended for shared use.

10. CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara

A simple straight to point mascara that gets the job done. This mascara is not at all expensive. With the characteristics of a good mad at and the affordability of a drugstore makeup brand, this mascara has to be one of the best finds.

This mascara gives you lashes that are ten times much longer and thicker than bare lashes. The drastic change between your natural eyelashes and lash Blasted eyelashes is absolutely stunning. The mascara treats every eyelash individually and gives you equally coated eyelashes with no clumps and are not very many to wear sound all day.

This light yet impactful mascara is also available in 4 colors, and each of them leaves a bold look on anyone who decides to use them. Covergirl cares about its customers and its environment and is created on a non-cruelty basis, and it does not test its products on animals. The ingredients used in the product are displayed openly and seen while purchasing the product, which helps identify ingredients that some might be allergic to.

What We Like!
  • Even application.
  • Good for daily use.
  • Has a hygienic use of instructions included!
Things to Consider!
  • There are some products which are shipped already a little damaged.

 A Complete Guide For Mascara

These are things you should be on the lookout for a while, buying a good mascara. This may be the best mascara review,  but we want to make sure that you know your stuff before buying into it.

Related: Best Wrinkle Serums

Application Brush

This is an essential point when it comes to buying mascara. Your application brush should be suitable for your lash line. This brush should have enough bristles to treat your lashes with care. If the bristles are too mixed into each other, it will make the result very uneven. If the bristles are very far out, this can make the outcome very clumpy and give you raccoon eyes.

Bristles on a good mascara should be very balanced to ensure they don’t mess up the application and give the perfect outlook.


The consistency of the liquid, which is inside of the bottle, matters a lot. Considering that the application is either made harder or much for efficiently easier with consistency. If the gel or the product inside of the mascara bottle is a little too runny, it would be harder to manipulate while applying it on the eyelashes. If too thick, it would cause the eyes to have an extremely clumpy look. The outcome. in both extremes would not be suitable for anyone to use. The best application consistency should not be too thick or thin. Easily applicable and easily removable.

Skin Suitability

The product inside of your mascara should be suitable for various types of skins. It should not be limited to only one type of skin; it should be something that can easily be used by people to various skins to ensure that a multitude of the crowd can use it. Mascaras should also be dark enough to match with different sorts of skin colors and hair textures to ensure that no one should feel left out. The best color for mascaras is known to be black.

Brush Size

The brush size matters just as much as anything in the entire mascara altogether. An application brush size should be perfect for your specific eye shape. Your eyelashes are shaped in certain ways, and your brush should be about the same size and shape to ensure you’re going to get a great application and volume.

Specific Outlooks

Your mascara should be able to fulfill your needs for enhancements. There are multiple sorts of mascaras which help your eyelashes in different ways. Either they will induce your eyes with much more volume or help make your lashes much longer than they already are. And some mascaras help in making your eyelashes both longer and fuller. So make sure that you’re buying something that will be according to your needs.

Bottle Size

Your mascara bottle needs to be a perfect size, and you need to be able to finish it before the expiration date is reached. This ensures that you’re not wasting money on buying a huge bottle of mascara, which you will not end up empty. The bottle shouldn’t be too small that you end up empty in 2 days. If you’re someone who uses mascara daily, you should go for a decent sized bottle to ensure you don’t run out.


You should not be spending an extensive amount buying mascara. There will be multiple sorts of mascaras that may cost a lot of money, but they are either luxury products or have a brand name that supports the buying of that specific product. There should be a few luxuries involved in buying that product, which will make it much easier for you to keep up with the price and make it feel like it’s worth what you spent.

Final Verdict

This best mascara review is an entire guide to getting you to learn all that you want to know about mascaras. This will help you know what types of mascaras should be bought and what type should suit you the best. This also contains multiple products that help in making it easier to order your favorite mascara online. The top-rated mascara on amazon is linked in this article.

FAQ’s about Best Mascara

Is it safe to share mascara with other people?

The simple answer is no. You should not share makeup products with anyone in general. You should not risk giving yourself eye infections just because you shared your eye products with them. Different sorts of bacteria live in multiple people’s eyelashes, and everyone has their own personal hygiene of maintaining their eyelashes. So be careful, and don’t share your mascara with anyone.

When does mascara expire?

Mascara does have an expiry date, just like any other makeup product. Mascaras have a straightforward indication that they have gone foul. Mascaras will start to smell foul or smell weird, and you should stop using it that instant. Mascara also starts to get clumpy when it starts to expire. This should not b used since it will react with your eyes and give you rash or possibly nasty eye infections. Or just read the expiration date on the back.

What are the correct ways to apply mascara?

The correct way of applying your mascara is to look up to a higher level and start at the bottom of your lash line and wriggle your mascara wand from the bottom. Make sure you’re going from bottom to top this way; you’ll be able to coat all of the lash strands equally and not form an extensive amount of clumps on your lashes. Repeat if needed.

What are the regulations followed to keep mascara safe?

It would help if you always kept your mascara too tightly shut and not be exposed to the air for a very long time. This would mainly protect the liquid inside from getting clumpy or getting dried out. You should also store your mascara in a dry place and not induce or thin it down with any liquids. This will ruin the mascara entirely, and you will have useless mascara.

Lily Roberts

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top