Best 4-Slice Toasters Consumer Ratings & Reports 2023

Nothing is more frustrating than having toast burned early in the morning. It upsets your mood, and you don’t feel like making it all over again.

Going without breakfast to your workplace is a mistake that depletes your energy before noon. So, what should you do?

First of all, toss away a toaster that burns your toast and mood. The second thing to do is to grab the best 4-slice toaster.

I know you will say that tons of options are out there. I don’t know what to pick.

Yes, different brands have an overwhelming display of pop-up toasters. A quick look at that display makes you confused.

Please don’t forget that I’m here to help with my detailed toaster buying guide that explains what factors to look for.

In this post, I am going to review the 7 best 4-slice toasters according to consumer ratingsa and reports 2023.

From altering the shade to making waffles and bagels at home, hi-tech designs of versatile toasters are a part of my list.

Every toaster in the list is highly recommended by consumers who care more about quality and healthy breakfast. So without further ado lets get started.


Here are the top-rated products we picked out that you would be interested in, depending on your budget…

Best 4 Slice Toasters Consumer Ratings & Reports

I have compiled a list of the 7 best 4-slice toasters based on consumer ratings and reports for 2023.

1. Cuisinart CPT-180P1 Metal Classic 4-Slice Toaster

Features at a glance
  • Quick Toasting
  • 7-shade settings
  • Extra-wide slots 1.38 inches
  • 1500 Watts Power

If you live in an RV or are always on the move, you can’t rely on outside bagels. In that case, you should buy this lightweight toaster from Cuisinart.

It is designed with a brushed stainless steel body that is easy to clean and lasts for a very long time.

There are dual control panels on this toaster that makes the toasting even and smooth.

You would surely like its overall design that has a brushed stainless steel body and chrome accents looks. This combination seems contemporary.

This cuisine is integrated with custom controls. There are six different settings with dials. You can make bagels quickly or use their reheating and defrosting functionality.

Thanks to its LED Indicators, you would know what you are doing.

With its 1.5 inches wide toasting slot, you can make fresh toast and bagels in no time. Always slide out its crumb tray during cleaning.

Dual control panels make these two toasters in one with smooth Brushed Stainless housing. It won’t take much storage space as it has a built-in cord storage option.

People having health concerns must know that this kitchen appliance is BPA-free. There is an instruction book that gives you perfect guidance about its usage.

What We Like!

  • Wide toasting slots
  • 3 Year Limited Warranty
  • Convenient cord storage
  • BPA Free

Things to Consider!

  • It doesn’t toast evenly.

2. Keenstone Stainless Steel Bagel Toaster 4 Slice

Features at a glance
  • High-Quality Stainless Steel Body
  • 5-inch slot
  • One-sided heating for Bagels
  • Built-in 4 functions
  • Beautiful Black Design and Look

Do you like to purchase a multi-functional toaster? If that’s the case, then you should go with this Retro Stainless steel toaster from Keystore.

It has an eye-catching look that will boost the aesthetic of your kitchen in no time. It lets you make bagels and bread at the same time.

It unlocks four different functions such as reheat, Defrost, Bagel, and cancel. So, you would be able to make the most of it.

When your heart goes to oil-free English muffins, you can make the most out of this toaster.

Working with this 4-slice toaster is super easy. It’s easy to lift the lever higher so it can reach the toasted bread.

When it comes to cleaning, you can remove its tray and then wipe it all up quickly.

One thing to keep in mind is that a Bagel toaster is one-sided. So, when you select this function, the bagel will be crunchy from the cut side. Another side won’t be toasted.

Thanks to its ultra-wide slot, you can make English muffins at home.

This toaster is made of stainless steel, a durable material that lasts longer and is relatively easy to clean. Every side will be toasted evenly when you put two slices of bread at a time.

What We Like!

  • Make bagel and bread simultaneously
  • Removable crumb tray for quick cleaning
  • Vintage toaster
  • User-friendly Design

Things to Consider!

  • Adjusting toasting time is a challenge.

3. Elite Gourmet ECT-3100 Maxi-Matic 4 Slice Toaster

Features at a glance
  • Quick Toasting
  • 7-shade settings
  • Extra-wide slots 1.38 inches
  • 1500 Watts Power

Do you like to make Texas toasts at home? If that’s the case, Elite Gourmet has just the perfect Maxi-Matic toaster for you.

It is powered by a 1300-watts heating element which will heat up toast fast and help you make quick bagels. Thanks to its extra-wide toasting slots, you can toast thick slices of bread.

You can choose from six different toasting levels. If you like other kinds of doneness and browning shade, this toaster will help you do it.

It’s easy to make crunchy toast with dark doneness or light brown as per your personal taste.

A reheating function ensures that you can warm up a toasted bread at a low temperature without burning.

If you want to release a toast in the middle of the toasting cycle, the cancel button is there to help you. This toaster is designed with a self-centering guide.

When you compress the lever, it will grab the bread in the center and toast it evenly.

You don’t need to worry about your money as the manufacturer is backed by the quality of its product with a 1-year warranty.

What We Like!

  • Self-Centering Guide
  • Easy to use Cancel Button
  • A quick cleaning with Crumb tray
  • 1-Year Warranty

Things to Consider!

  • The temperature Knob is loose.

4. Keenstone Stainless Steel 4  Slice Toaster with Extra Wide Slot

Features at a glance
  • Bagel Toaster
  • Beautiful Color and Look
  • Sturdy stainless steel body
  • Multiple Setting

When you need to handle the needs of a growing family, a 2-slice toaster isn’t good enough.

If you are out in the market to find a high-quality 4-slice toaster, please take a look at this Keenstore product.

The very first impressive thing about this toaster is its stainless steel design and beautiful appearance.

It blends beautifully in a modern kitchen. A combination of eclectic red with silver stainless steel is super stunning. If you are not so into red, go with another color- silver black.

Another thing to praise about this toaster is its wide slot. Every slot is 1.5 inches wide, so whether you want to toast regular bread or waffle, it’s a perfect width to put a slice into.

This toaster lets you make fresh English muffins and waffles to bring incredible variety to your breakfast table.

Working with this toaster is super easy. You put the bread in, adjust the setting, and Press lift down.

It takes less than a minute to give you crispy toast. The lever automatically pops up once toasting is done.

A wide variety of settings is there to help you. In a family where everyone is picky about their food, this toaster seems like a blessing. You can make waffles in one slot while toasting bread in another slot.

This nice-looking red-silver 4-slice toaster is designed with two removable crumb trays, making the cleaning process super easy.

What We Like!

  • Consistent Results
  • 5 inches Wide slot
  • Double Crumb Trays
  • Easy to Clean

Things to Consider!

  • It might dent up, be careful with its handling.

5. Proctor Silex 4-Slice Extra-Wide Slot Toaster

Features at a glance
  • Auto shut off
  • Customize Toast Shade
  • Neat storage
  • Toast small and big bread

Proctor Silex is designed with an extra-wide slot that lets you toast thick bread slices as quickly as you want. You can toast it evenly at a consistent heat pattern.

Cleaning-conscious people can keep their countertops super clean. There is a removable tray that holds the crumbs and makes the cleanup quick.

In case some toasts get stuck, it shuts off automatically. During a jammed cycle, you can enjoy peace of mind with its advanced design.

Besides, there is built-in down storage where you can wrap its cord. When this toaster isn’t in use, you can store it effortlessly.

Serving toast as per the family’s preference has become super easy. Seven built-in shade settings allow you to pick a shade as you like.

Press the Cancel button to remove the toast when you like it. The retrieval of small bread such as English muffins is easy, thanks to its toast boost lifter.

What We Like!

  • Easy to use
  • Easy retrieval of small bread
  • Wide slot for thick bread
  • Kitchen stays clean

Things to Consider!

  • It doesn’t thoroughly toast the big bread.

6. CUSIMAX Ultra-Clear LED Display 4 Slice Toaster

Features at a glance
  • 3-toasting functions
  • LED Display
  • Extra-wide slot
  • Removable crumb tray

If you are into hi-tech 4-slice toasters, it is available from Cusimax. The stainless steel body houses a digital display for easy reading and functioning.

You can toast small and large loaves of bread quickly with its extra-wide slot, which is 1.5 inches wide and 5.5 inches long.

It is pretty easy to deal with its multiple settings. You can adjust time and doneness settings from its large and clear display.

Preset buttons include defrosting, cancel, and bagel. So, this toaster is super helpful whether you want to make healthy bagels or plan to defrost the frozen item. Its defrosting function will warm the bagel; it won’t burn it at all.

When you press its cancel button, it will stop working and pop the bread out for a taste. The compact design won’t take much storage space and keep your counter neat and clean.

The stainless steel body is a perfect match for a modern kitchen. You can rotate the cord at 360 degrees during storage and then store it in the bottom space.

What We Like!

  • Space-Saver compact design
  • Six browning Settings
  • Countdown timer
  • Extra lift lever

Things to Consider!

  • The sides of the toaster heat up fast, be careful.

7. GE Stainless Steel Extra Wide 4 Slice Toaster

Features at a glance
  • Quick Toasting
  • 7-shade settings
  • Extra-wide slots 1.38 inches
  • 1500 Watts Power

You don’t have much time to prepare a crispy brown toast in the morning. Thereby, it would help if you always had a quick toaster; one such is available from GE.

This stainless steel toaster runs on 1500 Watts heating elements, so it can quickly toast bagels as quickly as you want. You don’t need to wait too long to get perfect looking toast.

It is integrated with 7-shade settings. Whether you are into light brown or golden brown, this toaster will help you get doneness as per preference and satisfaction.

Unlike other toasters that usually have small slots, this one is measured at 1.38″ x 5.50”. Thereby, you can easily make different types of bagels, waffles, pastries, and breads.

This four-slice toaster will make fresh bagels and loaves of bread for big families.

The stainless steel toaster is designed with a removable crumb tray. You can pull it out for easy cleaning.

Although it comes with four slots, this design is compact so that it won’t take up much space on your kitchen countertop.

This toaster is designed with preset functions, so you can make bagels or defrost frozen items.

What We Like!

  • Even heat and results
  • Easy Clean-up
  • Perfect Preset Functions
  • Button lights indicator

Things to Consider!

  • Cheap quality look.

4 Slice Toaster Complete Guide

Different brands integrated new and unique features in their pop-up toaster. When you explore the market, you will come across tons of styles, colors, and designs.

So, shopping for the best home use becomes a challenge, which you can readily overcome with my detailed buying guide below. Let’s get started.

Ease of Use

You don’t want to deal with complex design and functions early in the morning – no one has that much energy. Thereby, it is essential to buy a pop-up 4-slice toaster that is simple to use.

Cancel- Look for this feature as it allows you to cancel toasting anytime.

Defrost- Thawing frozen bread is a challenge that you can easily overcome with the defrosting option.

Digital Display: Some people don’t like to deal with buttons, so digital display makes overall handling quite simple.

Built-in cord storage: It is another feature that you can easily find in a toaster. It makes it easy for you to store this appliance after use.

Auto shut-off: Another helpful feature that makes use of this appliance pretty convenient is auto shut-off when toasting is done. It saves energy and also your bread from burning.

Indicator Lights: These lights will tell you what function is currently on.

High Lift: The lever of this toaster lifts bread high, so you can pick up ready bread without burning your hands.

Countdown timer: It will tell you how much time is left in a ready toast.


Be clear about what you want to do with a toaster. Some pop-up toasters are designed to make only crispy toast; they can’t do anything else.

However, others are designed to make bagels, waffles, and muffins. So, when shopping for this kitchen appliance, please keep in mind its intended use.

If you plan to use it only for a toaster, you can save money and buy a classic version. On the flip side, go with a multi-functional one when you like variety on your breakfast table.


You should always get a toaster that can help you make the most of multiple settings.

Some toasters have classic settings so that you can choose between light, medium, and dark browning. Others are advanced levels and bring almost six different browning levels.

They make it super simple for you to choose a shade and crispiness level when you live with a family where every family member likes a different shade of toast; only an advanced toaster becomes your ultimate breakfast assistant.

Heating Element

If you are a busy person who can’t wait much in the morning as work is waiting for you, get a toaster with a good heating element.

Look for a toaster with 1000 to 1500 watts of power. The best thing about this much power is that the toaster will heat up fast and do its job pretty quick.


The design of your Popup toaster also matters. Most are available with stainless steel housing that is easy to clean.

If you want to boost the aesthetic value of your kitchen, you can opt for colorful models such as black silver, red silver, and blackest black.

Slot Size

Try to buy an extra-wide slot size toaster. If you are wondering why then the simple answer is you can toast different sizes of bread conveniently.

When the slot is big enough, it provides enough room for large and thick bread. Thereby, if your kids like Texas bread or specialty bread, you can make it all in one appliance easily. You won’t have to visit the bakery quite so often.


If you are into classic type pop-up toasters, it won’t be very costly. It fits within your budget pretty well.

However, don’t buy very cheap toasters as their material is usually flimsy. After some use, it might break down.

I suggest you buy from renowned brands like Black and Decker, Cuisinart, and others.

Brands provide you a pop-up toaster made of stainless steel material, which is durable. It might cost you a bit extra, but again you can enjoy its benefit for a long time.

Ease of Cleaning

A toaster should be easy to clean. As you need to use it daily, its clean-up should be quick.

Many brands add a removable tray for the user’s convenience. You can empty this tray full of crumbs that makes cleaning simple and easy.


A toaster is a electrical kitchen appliance that can break down often.

If you have a warranty in your hand, you will be sure that customer support is there to help you. Top brands offer a 1-year warranty.

Consistent Results

One of the essential things to look for in a toaster is consistent browning results.

Some toasters create a light shade for the first batch and then start darkening it for the next batch.

Before you buy any toaster, please make sure that a toaster provides consistent results throughout its life.

Final Verdict

Every morning you can’t struggle with a bad quality toaster; you have work to handle and other chores to complete.

Breakfast is incomplete without crispy toast. So, when you buy a toaster, you should consider getting a 4-slice one.

It is the most suitable toaster for a big family. I have created a comprehensive buying guide that explains what things must look for during shopping for a pop-up toaster.

This guide explains that you can buy a classic toaster within your budget, but when you want to make bagel and waffle alongside a crispy toast, you need to spend a little more money on this.

Toasters are available in various shapes, designs, and styles; picking one won’t be that simple.

I curated top-7 4-slice toasters to make your life easier, which make customers happy and satisfied every morning.

FAQs About 4 Slice Toaster

How Many watts should a good toaster have?

The watts define the power and speed of toasting. Try to buy a toaster with more than 1300 watts as it will help you make Texas bread and waffles quickly.

How  Often Should You Clean a toaster?

If you use a toaster every other day, please clean it once a week to maintain your family’s health and hygiene. Weekly cleaning prevents sludge buildup.

How to Clean a 4-Slice toaster?

Remove the cord from the electric unit, turn it off. Now remove its crumb tray, empty it and wash it. Let it dry aside and take one soft brush to clean the interior.

Please never submerge a toaster in the water. You don’t need to use detergent to clean the interior. A damp cloth wipe is good enough to clean its exterior.

How Long Should a Toaster last?

If you buy a good quality toaster in a market, it lasts for six to eight years. However, it would be best if you cleaned a toaster to keep it functional for years properly.

Read More: Consumer Ratings & See all Blogs here

Ellen Thomas

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top